Categories: Energy Efficiency

Thank you, and goodbye, gas grid

Published by

Shuttershock

Our family is now off the gas grid. In March we installed an induction cooktop to replace our gas cooktop, which had been our last gas appliance. Everything in our house now runs off electricity including the oven, the solar hot water booster, the lawnmower and the barbeque. The exceptions are the two cars, but I hope to get an electric car next year. When that happens I’ll know enough about our home energy useage to install a suitable solar photovoltaic and battery storage system.
My aim is to save money and reduce our carbon and petrol emissions. That doesn’t mean we’ll go off the electricity grid, and I don’t want to. Our roof doesn’t suit a huge PV system so it would be easier and cost less upfront to get the balance of our energy from a renewable energy supplier, as we do now.
But I had no reservations going off the gas grid. Gas was easier and less costly to replace. It took three steps – choosing an electric oven when we did a major house renovation in 2011, replacing our very old gas hot water heater with electric boosted solar hot water in 2014, and now switching our cooktop from gas to induction.
Although the gas cooktop was in good working order, both the economic and the environmental advantages of changing were strong and the payback time is reasonable. After we replaced the gas hot water system, our gas useage plummeted and was $67 for the last year, all of it for cooking. $67 would have been OK if that was all we paid, but the additional $252 annual service charge just to be connected to the grid made cooking with gas expensive. Over the past year we also paid $24 in late payment fees, two lots of $12 each, even though payment was only a few days late. This was another reason why our customer loyalty was about zero.
I researched induction cooking and cooktops and bought a 2014 Choice report for $23 from which I identified 12 models that suited us. In the end, my wife and I narrowed our choice to the cheapest, an IKEA model at $699, and a Westinghouse at $1,261. The IKEA on sale was a newer model to the one in the report but all else looked the same so I assumed it would be close enough if not the same. When we inspected the IKEA and Westinghouse cooktops both looked good. My wife marginally prefered the IKEA. So did I when I got a $100 discount on the price by becoming an IKEA member for free and worked out that the price difference between the IKEA and Westinghouse would pay for the installation.
Installing the cooktop involved turning off the gas, removing the gas cooktop, and putting in a dedicated electric line to the meter box. The electrician who worked on our house renovation gave us what I thought was a very good quote – $495. But as he is good and gives good quotes we had to wait nearly a month to receive the quote and nearly another month to have the cooktop installed. It was worth it. At one point when my patience was low I got another quote – for $1,320. I said no, and fortunately and by coincidence our electrician’s quote came in only a few hours later.
The granite bench top needed a few millimetres shaved off along one edge so that bumped the final price to $550. And a small section of the inside part of the kitchen drawer under the cooktop had to be lowered by a few millimetres so the drawer could clear the bottom part of the cooktop. I was happy to get out my file but my wife wanted the kitchen people to do it. The kitchen man did a good job by lowering the whole inside part of the drawer and that was another $165. We had a couple of fry pans and a pot that work on induction cooktops but we had to spend another $190 on a wok and a couple of saucepans.
All these brought the total cost of the new cooktop to $1,527. Many of the other cooktops cost more than this alone so I am happy with the final cost.
I don’t know what the cooktop will cost to run, but induction cooking is meant to be energy efficient. If, hypothetically, it ends up costing about the same in electricity as we paid for gas – $67 for the last 12 months – that means we save the service charge of $252 per year. That would make the payback period about five and half years, which is fine, and less in practise as the service charge is bound to go up over that time.
Also important is that the induction cooktop is enjoyable to use, and is safer in that it has no flame and shuts down when there is no cookware on the surface.
Going off the gas grid is a key step in our home clean energy strategy. It’s taken a few years to implement, and started with an electric lawn mower. Then lots of roof and wall insulation and an electric oven during our renovation. To better insulate our home I padded our door jambs with seals and put snakes under three of the external doors. In 2013 I bought a gauge and reduced our standby power, and I replaced an old airconditioner with a new energy efficient model. In 2014 I replaced our old gas hot water system with an electric boosted solar hot water system (click here).
I replaced our compact flourescent globes and some old incandescent globes with LEDs (click here).
And I replaced the glass on our back sliding doors and kitchen window with energy efficient Comfortplus glass. We’ve started this year by installing an induction cooktop and going off the gas grid.
But the job is not finished. Some key appliances need to be replaced – a very old fridge, an ailing dishwasher and a temperamental washing machine. But I don’t know when, probably when they break down. Some preliminary research showed we could save about a hundred dollars or more a year in running costs on a modern equivalent to our fridge. So the savings would be useful.
A big step would be trading in my faithful Toyota for an electric city run-around. I can’t afford it yet, but may be able to do so next year. Again, early research shows that about $750 to $1,000 in electricity would replace about $3,000 to $4,000 a year in petrol. There would also be savings in servicing and spare parts. In seven years or so my electric lawnmower hasn’t cost a cent for oil, servicing and spare parts. While a car is not that simple, I read the manual to see what is required to service a Nissan Leaf and it’s peanuts compared to a petrol driven car.
If I get an electric car, at that point all of our home’s energy except for the second car would come from electricity. I think that would be a good time to have a serious look at rooftop solar and by then there should be many battery systems on the market.
Having come this far, I can say that saving money and helping the environment are also interesting and a lot of fun.
Victor Bivell is editor of Eco Investor magazine. See http://www.ecoinvestor.com.au

This post was published on April 12, 2016 3:47 pm

View Comments

  • Thanks Victor. Are you able to say in what region you live? (Sorry if I missed that info in your article!)
    In Melbourne, our gas-supply charges went up by 25% at the beginning of the year, and have gone up 75% in five years. Gas suppliers are chasing people from the gas grid in Melbourne.

  • Great stuff Victor. Good to get to know your usage before taking the plunge into solar + battery.
    If you want to see one test case for a solar hybrid system I've got a Powerwall running with statistics over at
    http://unleashthepowerwall.com
    We've got gas hot water continuous flow system, and the main thing that bugs me about it is lead time. It takes ages to warm up, wasting precious water to do so. It is on the list to get replaced by a solar alternative when it breaks down.
    We've also got a gas cook top. This is a much tighter sell to replace, as we like cooking with gas, as flame works better for many foods. The induction option also requires replacing nearly all our cookware, so it's not an easy decision.
    Keep us all updated as you go.

  • Thank you Gas, and goodnight. Your 80% efficiency can't compete with 400% for electricity.

  • Well done. Our household said goodbye to the gas grid last year, as part of a house renovation inspired by energyfreedom.com.au. We found an induction cooktop and oven for a good price at a scratch and dent sale. I find induction to be easier, faster, more adjustable and easier to clean than gas. All the pots and pans work.
    Hot water is via a Sanden hot water heat pump using ~ 2 kWh/day of solar PV energy (less in summer) that would otherwise spill to the grid, thus costing about 12 c/day in foregone feed in tariff.

  • We are also contemplating going all electric. We have gas hot water and gas stove. The obvious replacement for the gas stove, is, as you have mentioned, an induction stove. Not so sure about a replacement for our gas hot water though. We have an instantaneous gas hot water system which has been pretty good. We really like the idea of not having to store and reheat water. If there was an electric equivalent to the instantaneous gas hot water system it would be easy. But I think you need 3-phase electricity for that?

  • Thanks for your insights Victor. We are not on the gas grid but our cooktop is a innefficient barely controllable electric ceramic model that I have been wanting to replace with an induction cooktop for too long. I have been hoping the costs would have come down more by now but it seems that the big name players are trying to gouge their their customers when, like me they want to upgrade their appliances to this new technology. Well screw them! Your article has incentivised me to install an Ikea induction cooktop in place of my overpriced, poorly performing Bosch ceramic cooktop!

Share
Published by
Tags: gasoff-grid

Recent Posts

Solar Insiders Podcast: A roller coaster year in review – and the keys to a smoother 2025

In our final episode for the year, SunWiz's Warwick Johnston on the highs and the…

December 20, 2024

“Nightmare:” Energy tariffs that are blowing out bills, blindsiding consumers

Regulator report finds that little-understood but increasingly common demand tariffs can add up to $800…

December 20, 2024

Hidden cost of rooftop solar? Actually, networks spend next to nothing on managing exports

Have you heard the one about non-solar homes paying the cost to networks of accommodating…

December 19, 2024

With just $500 of rooftop solar modules, you could charge your EVs for 20 years

Four good quality solar panels - costing around $500 - would produce enough power for…

December 19, 2024

“It makes no sense:” How fossil gas industry is blocking electrification and consumer savings

The gas war still burns: “We need to think about how to stop misinformation going…

December 17, 2024

SwitchedOn Podcast: Pathway to electrification being blocked by fossil gas

IEEFA's Amandine Denis-Ryan explains why new gas supplies are not needed in the long term,…

December 16, 2024