The real problem with network demand: air-con and pool pumps

Data from Australia’s first large-scale smart grid project have revealed that typical suburban households with air-conditioning and pools used between 80 and 97 per cent more energy than their neighbours who had neither.
The results of the study, published online in Elsevier’s international journal Energy and Buildings, found that Sydney houses with ducted air-conditioning used 79 per cent more electricity than those without, while the 15 per cent of households surveyed which had pools had an annual electricity demand 93 per cent higher than those without pools.

Undertaken by the School of Photovoltaic and Renewable Energy Engineering at the University of New South Wales (UNSW) and funded by the CRC for Low Carbon Living (CRCLCL), the study used data from the Australian Smart Grid Smart City project, as well as household surveys.
CRCLC Integrated Buildings Systems Program Leader and study co-author, Associate Professor Alistair Sproul said the results would help policy makers and planners measure the impact of different housing types and housing trends on local electricity demand.
“We found that air-conditioning and pools were the top two drivers,” said Sproul. “Overall the data collected showed a variety of patterns and behaviours for different households and residential building types so when planning for new dwellings we can accurately measure the future energy demand and find ways to make a residential building project more energy efficient.
“A key reason for the study was that in the residential sector, which represents around 30% of global electricity consumption, the underlying composition and drivers of energy use have until now been poorly understood,” said Professor Sproul.
Between 2010 and 2014 the Australian Smart Grid Smart City project collected electricity readings at half-hour intervals from 9903 households in six major towns or regions and 730 smaller towns across New South Wales.
The study used this detailed material to build a household electricity consumption model which was then linked and compared to detailed demographic information and housing survey results from some 3400 households to paint a detailed picture of consumption.
“This statistical model investigated the consumption of both individual households and communities,” said UNSW PhD student and lead author Hua Fan.
“There are limits to what can be achieved modelling single households given the myriad factors that go towards overall consumption including, importantly, the behaviour of the people living there. However, the model tested extremely well for forecasting the overall electricity consumption of communities.
“…Models like this are useful to a range of stakeholders, including individual households striving to understand the implications of different choices they might face such as whether to put a pool in, utilities looking to better forecast the impact of different residential trends as they plan their networks, as well as policy makers seeking to improve energy efficiency.”
Of all the homes surveyed 79% owned the home they lived in either outright (40%) or were mortgaged (29%); 19% had ducted air-conditioning, 50% split-system, 3% other and 28% no air-conditioning; 23% had a pool pump; 13% were units, 2% semi-detached and 85% were separate houses; and the average size of a trial household was 2.8 people.
UNSW electrical engineering Associate Professor Iain MacGill – another of the report’s co-authors – said the study was undertaken in the context of a largely unexpected fall in Australian residential electricity consumption over the past decade.
“This… caught the industry and policy makers by surprise given near continuous growth in consumption over the 100 year history of the electricity industry in Australia,” MacGill said.
“While very welcome in terms of households reducing their electricity bills, slowing excessive network investment and contributing to falling greenhouse gas emissions, we don’t fully understand what drove this fall and how we might even facilitate greater improvements.
“Studies such as this can also make a useful contribution towards assessing recent efforts by some of the network businesses, under pressure from falling revenue due to lower sales, to change their tariff arrangements.
“In particular, how can we ensure that households undertaking energy efficiency activities or putting on solar home systems are not penalised for doing the right thing in saving both money and the environment, whilst still ensuring we all fairly contribute towards reliable and secure supply,” he said.